I’m finding this review quite hard to write and had originally decided not to even do one. You see, like most people who love reading and particularly those who love high or epic fantasy, I have an admiration for The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. But when a well meaning family member bought me The Simarillion I found that I just couldn’t get into it. The same for The Lost Tales etc. Basically when it comes to Tolkien I love only stories with Hobbits in them.
Trying to read anything else about the history of Middle Earth, for me, is like forcing my way through Beowulf or Ivanhoe. It just becomes tedious, boring and I struggle to get into it. I don’t profess myself to be a reader of grand texts. I like a story I can get into it. And that’s why this review is hard. While I fully respect the work of art that is Beren and Lúthien I just didn’t really enjoy it.
The beginning part of the novel is mostly a preface and notes from the editor; Christopher Tolkien. One thing I certainly did like was this section and the other explanations, extracts from letters etc which are spotted around in the different chapters. I also enjoyed the actual story of Beren and Lúthien because it was fairly short and easy to understand. But for the most part the book is mainly very long and boring poetry. That part I didn’t like so much. It was worth a read all in all but I can’t say I’ll be rushing to pick it back up again!